Jump to content

Saishu

Veterans
  • Content Count

    2228
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    8

Posts posted by Saishu


  1. Arguments over semantics on the Internet is a terrible idea.

    That said, anything along the lines of "well that's your opinion" isn't much of an argument to begin with. The only thing that drives me even crazier is when I criticize a band and someone responds with "well what music have you written?" or "well how many records have you sold?"


  2. I think it's fair to hold a band to a certain standard, and Master of Romance showcased Sadie's influence without being too obvious. And while I get that it's extremely common and often encouraged that jrock/VK bands copy songs from other artists, it still bothers me. It shows a lack of creativity, and it's even worse when you know the band has talent but settles on ripping off riffs, arrangements, etc.

    I'm not entirely sure the DEG/Sukekiyo comparisons is accurate, since the whole idea of a side project is to create music that doesn't fit with the vision of your main project. I don't hear many similarities between them aside from the familiarity of Kyo's vocals. My issue with the THIRTEEN is that so far it just sounds like Sadie stealing another song. I'll admit it's not a fair assumption since very little is out there to judge, but that's my initial reaction.

    As far as expressing opinions here, I'm sure we can agree that "This band fucking sucks" is just as pointless and non-constructive as "I love everything these guys do." But not everyone is going to take the time to give detailed reasons why they feel a certain way. But if it ever comes down to "if you don't like it, don't comment", well, I'm going to point out how ridiculous a concept that is. It's very rare for a group of people from all over the world to unanimously share an opinion, especially over music.


  3. Let's not get too crazy and have varying opinions, folks.

    Speaking for myself, the reason why I continued to follow Sadie despite being continuously disappointed for years is because I kept hoping they would do something that was as good as Master of Romance. They never did, and Maria de Madrigal made me angry because I can't remember the last time I heard a bunch of songs that were so blatantly copies of another band's material.

    So here we are with a new project with dudes from Sadie, and it still just sound like Sadie. Sadie "covering" Dir en grey. Again. Sure, we can all just write it off and not comment on how annoying it is, but it's a public forum and everyone has different thoughts and opinions on things. It can't all be positive. In fact, it shouldn't all be positive. I understand VK fans tend to be ridiculously devoted to their favorite bands, but they tend to take criticism of the band as personal attacks.


  4. Finally sat down and gave these guys a listen, and I'm half impressed. When they're heavy, they're actually HEAVY, and I think a lot of that is due to the drummer truly understanding how metal drumming works. On the other hand, when they do that weird shuffle beat jazz stuff, I check out.

×
×
  • Create New...